Dear Colleagues:
Art is an esoteric undertaking. My photographs, your paintings, his sculptures and her batiks all appeal to a select crowd of people. Some lucky artists are more popular at appealing to the masses, but for the most part, artwork is intended to elicit response from the few. We are lucky if the many like it, but we know inherently that only a small percent of any population will ever be interested in what we have to say. Even many of the historic greats only found fame long after they had passed away, unable to find an audience during their lifetimes.
So it always is a blow to our collective egos when places where we are welcome, places where we are popular, places where our works are understood go away. Recently, as you know, our community lost several galleries; Margo, Marcus and Space Available just to name a few, closed or announced they will close soon. It appears, at least in the press, that the El Paso art scene is at the lowest point in some time. I would beg to differ.
Galleries are like friends; some stay around for a long time like Adair Margo and Hal Marcus, and some are new acquaintances, like SpAG. But also like friends, they can move on, change directions and of course, eventually die.
We shouldn’t mourn them because they are gone, but rather be glad we had a chance to know them to begin with and that they gave us a chance to show at all.
Margo’s gallery really didn’t cater to us anyway. Hers was focused on mostly out-of-town buyers and a few select local artists. It worked for her and her clients, and more power to her. After a good run over many years, she decided to move on. Remember, friends come and go. Margo stayed a long time, and actually will still be in the community, just not as visible as in the past.
Marcus’ gallery was personality driven, a name brand so to speak. When he sold it to his underlings, the reason for its existence ceased to exist as well. Recently he returned, I think knowing that the Hal Marcus Gallery probably should have Hal Marcus in it somewhere besides on the street sign. So it really didn’t close at all, just reorganized.
SpAG was a concept gallery that not many of us were familiar with: Rent the wall you want to display on. As close to a true democratic gallery as El Paso has ever seen, if you had the rent and something to show you could show. Good, bad, and lots of in-between hung on the walls of SpAG, but I think that the concept was a bit ahead of its time for our artistic community. I suspect we will see a SpAG-like gallery arise from the ashes again. The idea was too good to die.
Glancing through the May 2008 El Paso Scene one would be hard pressed to say that we are lacking wall space or galleries in our city. We might say that we are showing in places that we wouldn’t normally show, like coffee houses or restaurants or even our own homes, but to even think we are without walls in our city would be misleading. We may be without walls that we are familiar with, but the walls are still there.
However, if we really think we are in an artistic crisis in El Paso, might I suggest that we as an art community begin to rethink how we approach art in El Paso? Here are some suggestions that I think would go a long way to helping us help our fellow El Pasoans understand art:
First, we need to do a better job educating the community. El Paso isn’t the kind of place where folks typically run down to the corner gallery to see the latest in Impressionism or plein air watercolors. Art is not and has never been a cultural priority in our city as it is in others. Someone wrote recently that people in El Paso have to choose between food and art. I refuse to believe that. If we can afford to keep Starbucks running, we can afford to buy some art. The trouble is, El Paso as a whole does not seem to understand the importance of art, and I think it is incumbent on us to educate the community.
If someone came up to one of us and asked why value a piece of art, why that sculpture, why that photograph was important enough to buy, what would we say? Could we give a really good reason? (Go ahead, fill in the blank: The last piece of art that I made is important to you, the potential buyer, because_______.)
I know we know the answer, but can we explain it enough to a potential buyer? If we can’t easily explain it to ourselves, then we cant expect others to understand.
Could we answer these questions if a fellow El Pasoan asked us about a piece of art that we are trying to sell:
Why do I need this?
Why are you considered a good artist?
Why is this considered art and not craft?
Why should I pay for it?
I think if we all started doing a better job educating people about the need for art, we would see more galleries opening than closing and we would start selling more of our work. In school, we are pretty good at showing kids how to do art, but we rarely ever tell them why to do art. Maybe if we start with our young people, we can raise a generation that would actually appreciate art and stay in the city at the same time.
Secondly, we need to get rid of our “Field of Dreams” attitude. Build it and they will come? We need to stop listening to voices from elsewhere and start listening to the voices down the street or at the dinner table instead; they are El Paso. We need to stop self-congratulating each other and start asking people that are not artistically inclined about what they think of our artwork. They are the ones who know what is going on here. (If those outside voices were correct, we would be selling more work by now.) Just because we create something doesn’t mean people will come and buy it. (I recently gave a show on the colors of cemeteries and asked a gentleman at the opening which one of my photos he liked the best? “None” was the response. Instead of being insulted, I asked why he didn’t like the work. He explained his reasons, and was actually quite happy that I had asked his opinion. After a few minutes of explaining what I was trying to show, he warmed up to the concept of the show, and actually mentioned that now, he might come back and buy a piece. Education.)
When was the last time any one of us supported an artist that we didn’t know? Do we have any local art hanging in our houses that wasn’t a gift? What was the last piece of art from a local artist that any of us bought at full price in a gallery? We need to walk the talk if we want others to do the same.
We can build it, paint it, sculpt it, click it all we want, but unless we let people know about it, let them understand it, and promote ourselves, no one will come.
Thirdly, we need to get together and decide that we as a collective are more powerful than any one of us alone. Other cities have great cooperative art projects for struggling and new artists who mentor each other. We don’t see that a lot in El Paso. There are a few places where there are the embryonic beginnings of it, such as some web-based collaborations, but for the most part, we keep to ourselves, and that is not healthy or helpful.
Sadly, this creative group doesn’t talk to that creative group, this age group doesn’t talk to that age group, and this side of town doesn’t understand the struggles on the other side of town. We need to get over it, grow up, and start working together as a unified artistic group: a community. We have the creativity. We need the drive. Lets show El Paso how working together improves life in our city. Working together only makes all of us stronger. Embracing all types of work can only stir creativity, it can never dampen it.
Finally, we need to stop pricing ourselves out of the local market. I think it would be better to get our names out there in more houses and in more offices, and the way to do that is to start selling low. As our names get better known, we can raise our prices. I once had someone tell me that if I priced my work too low, no one would take me seriously. I listened, and for the first few shows I did, I didn’t sell a thing. Maybe because it was so serious, no one could afford me. When I started offering photos that El Pasoans could actually afford, I immediately found that I could sell them. Now, I actually have a few people that I regularly sell to. Imagine that: I have patrons.
So, arts colleagues, there are some ideas that should get us going. Additionally, we should move on from there and begin to think about making El Paso the national center for Hispanic and Chicano art. We could have a series of free shows in which any artist in town can offer work. Forget juries. Let the market be the jury. We could make it a big event at Cohen Stadium like the Armory Show in New York, but for our community and not as high priced.
How about turning Mc Kelligon Canyon into an artist zone where any artist can exhibit for free each weekend, kind of like the Indian Market in Santa Fe, but where everyone is welcome and it goes for months at a time?
We could make greater use of our museums to teach our little ones and their parents the “why of art,” instead of just showing them the “who of art.”
All we have to do is use a little imagination and our recent downturn in art can be easily turned around. Then, instead of reading about the weekly gallery closing, we can be celebrating the weekly gallery opening.














Rich Wright
April 11, 2008
This is the kind of enlightened responsible vision El Paso needs. Not victimization politics. It's not the market's fault if you don't understand the market. Educate and adapt.
Marty
April 11, 2008
Tim is right.
I asked El Paso artist Bill Kolliker, back in 1985, why I don't see more of his work being seen and sold in El Paso. And he said "why bother" and "it's too much work to sell art here".
And he said his work sells all the time in Scottsdale, AZ.
Personally, I see people buying mass-produced paintings,
sofa size and smaller being sold for hundreds of dollars at
furniture retailers, but the same buyers would not buy local-original art for the same price. Go figure.
Several really good El Paso artists have moved to Santa Fe to
make and sell their art. And I've seen artists get just an address/ PO Box in Santa Fe, just so they can put on their sign / tent/ space/ "from Santa Fe". and people whisper................ "he's from Santa Fe" honey, let's buy some art from him".
Well, I don't have the answer to the age old question of why El Pasoan's don't buy art here. But, I am trying to understand it.
Keep it going Tim !
David K
April 12, 2008
I'm very impressed Mr. Holt's approach to what he sees as a problem. I personally can't stand the "art community" and it is mostly because they sit around whining about how nobody appreciates them. Mr. Holt is not whining. He comes up with a solution.
Make the face of art in this town resemble that of Mr. Holt's attitude and you will have galleries packed with people and plenty of places to show.
Always remember that this town has many needs - arts, parks and jobs to name just a few. With a positive and industrious attitude like Mr. Holt's we can meet all those needs.
Mr. Holt - thank you for making me dislike the arts community a lot less.
M. Carter
April 12, 2008
Tim, I loved your article and the recommendations that you made. Please note that some artists and art organizations have formed and Ad Hoc Arts Advocacy Group in collaboration with the Museums and Cultural Arts Department (MCAD) and Genesis 21, a private consulting firm. The group is currently working on an economic development report in coordination with the Americans for the Arts to show the importance that art has on the economy of the City. Other issues they are tackling include Education and Marketing as those have been identified as the highest areas of need. As someone who works for EPISD, as an inside person I would encourage you to advocate for the arts and for the schools to open their doors to artists and art organizations as the arts have also been proven to advance education and will help develop the future artists, audiences, and arts advocates we so desperately need in El Paso. Get involved with EPISD's recent Arts Committee to help ensure increase and ensure the integration of the arts in your District.
I loved your letter as it hits many points that need to be addressed and you're right collaboratively we can make difference.
LisaT
April 13, 2008
You made this statement:
"The trouble is, El Paso as a whole does not seem to understand the importance of art,"
Maybe it's you that doesn't understand.
You can't sell snow blowers in El Paso so why do you keep trying. Find out what the market desires. Then fill that need. OH lets not forget to take your nose out of the clouds. Pretentious people don't make sales.
Marty
April 13, 2008
Like any product, you have to find out what people WANT.
Ao........ What DOOOOOOOOOOO they want?
Let's see... velvet paintings once had a life of their own.
Then, around late 1960's - and early 1970's Southwestern Art
made an inroads ( Indians, cowboys, Indian & western paintings of
pottery, adobe homes, God's eye paintings, cows, horses, mountains, etc.)
Now, I somehow feel that Southwestern art is out. Gone. Over.
Each period in time has a feel to the arts. However, starting
right ............................. NOW....................... The new generations
of young adults care nothing about art, or paintings or decor.
All (and of course I mean the majority of young adults, not just
a handful) of these new adults and new families spend their money
on TV's, computers, ipods and snap together furniture.
From this time on, I don't see any real desire for these new adults and families to care about art, antiques, their family heirlooms,
grandma's antique jewelry or anything like that.
I see them selling all of the family heirlooms as fast as they inherit them to pawn shops and on ebay.
I think the older adults that are around today are the last generation to even care about art, antiques, heirlooms and the such.
So what's left is............... all new art will have to appeal to
these new young adults and families, like .... dark... goth...
bloody.... grunge ... industrial ...
Just follow the music scene and you'll see where this is going.
We are not going... back to the 50's. (Elvis and more)
or the 60's (Beatles and more)
Things change. The people have changed.
I've seen art shows here and elsewhere go by the wayside like
Kermazzar here, dwindle to nothing or back to their beginnings
as the demand is not there anymore for art, sculpture and handmade things and furniture that will last a lifetime.
I don't think there will be many traditional families anymore
to have a home to care about to put art in.
50% are high school dropouts now. This never happened before.
(Except during the great depression, - 1929, where all the kids had to drop out to work, just so the family could eat.)
So, I guess, it's not just about art, but several traditional items are going by the wayside, all at the same time.
And .... just one Nuclear reactor or anything like that, having a leak
or ...worse... will end this book, as we know it.
Like the Boy Scouts motto: "Be Prepared".
.... You are on your own.
maria gonzales
April 13, 2008
Making art more approachable to the average person is a must, especially for this market. I know many people feel intimidated to walk into a gallery. What if they ask me questions? I don't have a clue about art. Noone wants to feel stupid. Take note from the way the big successful retailers bring in their customers, have smaller inticing items at the door that most people may be able to afford, large easels with information people can read, or a video playing of the artist or artists at work at their craft, to ease them in the door. Lots of research money is spent by retailers to sell products, copy the best. Make it fun. Wearable art, t-shirts etc.
Marty
April 13, 2008
To have art in your home or office:
to like it, it must make you FEEL GOOD.
All the art I have, when I look at it, expresses an emotion
and makes me and others... feel good.
I like the idea Tim has of a McKelligon Canyon art project,
or Sunday mornings in the Cohen Stadium to sell art
at reasonable prices.
A lot of the art sold now, seems to be the type:
"Nothing over $20.00, type of thing, plus framing."
People seems to be attracted to a firm - reasonable price
and know that in advance.
At a good price point: $10. - $20. - $30.
I know that artists would probably be making less than "minimum wage" offering art for such prices, but once you get into a half or a whole EL Paso paycheck.... now it becomes serious buying.
El Paso artist Bill Kolliker told me once that he made the inexpensive owl type etchings so that the buyers would move on up to his thousand dollar watercolors. So, he understood the price thing to get buyers interested.
Del Pueblo Press
April 13, 2008
Nice article. It hits on some of the core issues that keeps art in El Paso in the shadows. Mr. Holt, please contact us at your convenience. We have some suggestions which may add momentum to your vision. Warm regards.
LisaT
April 14, 2008
Forgot to mention this. Just how much Art do you think a family of 4 can afford on a gross income of $20,000 or less. Many in EL Paso are working multiple jobs just to keep a roof over their heads and food on the table and many can't even do that. Art is not in their budget.
Mary Nieto
April 14, 2008
Although it may seem that El Pasoans do not flock to art galleries, do you believe that if a Herculian effort were to be made by the Museum to bring BIG exhibits - such as Tut - El Pasoans would flock to that?
Albert R
April 14, 2008
Inclination towards art is a human quality, not a rarified grace. El Pasoans like everyone else are indeed “artistically inclined,” except perhaps to different levels of “art” from what some artists consider to be true art and not “crafts” or kitsch. Although art is of great importance to any civilization, nobody ever needs art. Any putative El Paso artist would therefore do well to look at their art “market.” It’s almost common sense that appreciation of fine art closely parallels social class, i.e., income level and educational attainment. The great French sociologist Pierre Bourdieu wrote about social class and taste decades ago in several books, most notably in "Distinction." It takes refinement of intellect (and a big purse) to appreciate and value art the way you want your viewers to do so. You should take a look at income and education demographics of El Paso for your answers. They are available online at the U.S. Census website. If you choose not to go where art is appreciated and valued and selling at a premium, and you’re trying to make your living at it; perhaps budget, volume production art is a good idea. There may be some consumers of high art in El Paso, but they are just as likely to do their buying in Santa Fe, or even Old Mesilla. Oh, and as for a potential center for Chicano art, keep in mind that when the C.A.R.A. exhibit (Chicano Art: Resistance and Affirmation) hit town during its national tour in the early nineties,…an art spawned by perhaps the only genuine cultural phenomenon and political movement to which El Paso has ever given birth,…the powers that be at the El Paso Art museum in their inscrutable wisdom changed the name to the less ethnically charged “Hispanic Reality.” As for Hispanic art, New Mexico has the corner on that market.