I was part of a team that submitted for the Upper Valley Traffic Study; our team was not selected. But I know well the extent and importance of this work, and the difficulty involved in a thorough analysis. And I know what this work costs to do well.
In 1981-1982, I worked on a master plan and rezoning of several thousand acres of land in Northwest El Paso (South of Artcraft to north of Transmountain; I-10 east to the toe of the mountain slope). At the time, the cross-Valley highway on the MTP (Major Thoroughfare Plan) was designated at Borderland Road. Redd Road also was identified for a Valley crossing. I discussed with my client relocating the connecting thoroughfare (I-10 to the state line, then to Santa Teresa) from Borderland to Artcraft Road.
There were numerous reasons for relocating the connection. First, the Borderland Road at I-10 was in a major drainage (100-year storm flow about equal to 1/3 the Rio Grande at flood stage); second, the number of properties to be acquired through purchase/eminent domain would have exceeded 100. Third, right-of-way existed along Artcraft, and the number of property owners to be dealt with in Texas was significantly lower. Fourth, there was open land available at Doniphan that could accommodate on-off ramps. Fifth, the Borderland neighborhood ("La Borla") would have been devastated, dividing an older community (Environmental Justice before it was a term).
My client told me he did not believe I would be successful, but to go ahead and try, because it made sense. The process took over a year, and I was successful. New Mexico built their part of the road; Texas lagged, but Artcraft finally opened near the turn of the century. One must live a long time to see results of labor.
Earlier, I had been involved with a subdivision in the Valley, west of Montoya Road; the owner was required to donate right-of-way for the extension of Redd Road. I told the City of El Paso in 1979 and again in 1982 that I believed they lacked the political will to build Redd, irrespective of its importance, interchange link, etc. Prescient.
I also worked with potential cross-sections for Country Club, to determine whether reasonable improvements could be made within existing right-of-way to improve its operation. The answer then was yes; still is.
The importance of this discussion has to do with the function of an economic region. We live in one that extends from northern Mexico to Alamogordo, Las Cruces, and beyond. The State of New Mexico, and its entire congressional delegation to Washington, support economic development in southern Doña Ana County. This is important, as the Santa Teresa area includes over 30,000 acres of private land. Much more is held by federal and state agencies. Opposite, at San Jerónimo, Mexico, lie over 40,000 acres of private land. There is no river; the Port of Entry can be expanded with a bulldozer, not a bridge. Rail connection to Mexico is relatively straightforward, also. Activity is moving rapidly on the Union Pacific rail facilities, which will be accompanied by relocation of several hundred well-paying jobs; New Mexico quickly provided the railroad with about everything they needed to incentivize the development.
Doña Ana County’s Foreign Trade Zone in the area recently was expanded significantly. There is an airport, already the site of package freight operations, with promise of more; many private planes are based there; the main runway expansion is under construction; another runway is on the planning boards; and there is a great little air museum.
Local roads will be realigned, and new ones constructed. An excellent highway connects Santa Teresa to the west; the High Mesa Road connecting Santa Teresa to I-10 west of Las Cruces has been on the planning boards for ten years. And due to the transportation links, location of major federal facilities is very possible, and likely.
The University of Phoenix has an apparently successful operation at Santa Teresa. Both water and sewer are available throughout the region, including much of the Mesilla Valley (allowing lots of 6,000 square feet). There are State economic incentives to develop horse properties in the Sunland Park area. That community is working toward a port of entry.
Some say El Paso should not build roads for New Mexicans to drive here to work. Quite the contrary, in the long term. El Pasoans very likely will be driving to New Mexico to work. Until they move there.
I will be interested in the results of the Upper Valley Traffic Study. I also will be very critical of it, if the numerous discoverable issues are not included in the analysis. The region and area will grow significantly. The last thing El Paso should do is what Albuquerque did, regarding Rio Rancho, which is now the third largest city in New Mexico. Santa Teresa could displace it, in record time.
***
Wayne Grinnell has been involved in private and public sector land planning and development in the El Paso, Texas/Southern New Mexico region for over 30 years. He is a member of the Counselors of Real Estate (CRE) and the American Institute of Certified Planners (AICP). He is Vice-President of Planning and Development of the CSA Design Group in El Paso.
















Ed Leonard
April 10, 2008
Wayne-
This is an intelligent and insightful analysis. In the contemporary U. S., development very seldom stops at state lines. Instead, it often accelerates there. A lot of El Paso's desirable development will be on the West Mesa. We all need to be ready for it!
Ed Leonard
Mike
April 10, 2008
Thank you for this information. People need to get out of this old mentality that El Paso needs to wait and see. Stop being reactionary and look to the future. Some on city council see this others are still stuck in the "not in my backyard" mentality. Old leaders let the city get to this point and now in some cases it will be harder to fix. People love to complain about issues, but don't want to offer solutions or be a part of the solution if it affects them.
Dan
April 10, 2008
Now you've done it! You went got an expert to write on the subject. Oh what will we ever do now? Speculation, innuendo and flat out lies will not stand up to this. I guess that takes 70% of the know-it-alls out of the equation.
Rudy Mata
April 11, 2008
Wayne,
Very good analysis. Many of us share your regional view on planning but few of us can articulate it so clearly and with the benefit of the perspective of a "seasoned" planning professional. Recall several years ago during the Texas and NM joint APA chapter conference in El Paso practically all the mayors in our region signed a pledge to work toward regional solutions to our urban planning issues such as transportation. Perhaps we need dig up that document and post it on NPT. Thanks for sharing your thoughts on this important issue.
--Rudy
Elizabeth Wesstrom
April 12, 2008
I believe Country Club Road should remain for the residents of beautiful valley with a bike lane on either side and that is it! The traffic to and from Santa Teresa and the far west should be kept on Mc Nutt and continue into El Paso with a new entry road over the sandbanks entering on to 1 10 with a new entrance at Executive or before. The Cross Roads and the Mesa entrance on to 1 10 has too much traffic now. The traffic from Santa Teresa entering Country Club wants to get on to 1 10 going East . Yes New Mexico would need to pay for part of this to the River. Now is the time to say no no to more destruction of the Upper Valley !
Elizabeth Wesstrom
Mark B.
April 14, 2008
Proponents of the growth of Santa Teresa have always known it would be at the expense of El Paso. Many of us here in El Paso understand that to be true. Wayne reveals himself when he writes these comments :
1. about El Pasoans building roads to NM until they move there?
2. the relocation of several hundred well paying jobs because of the railroads to NM
3. regional economic development and does not mention El Paso but only NM
4. University of Phoenix?
This article reveals itself for what is is...a NM plan to take what El Paso has as a major trade HUB but they already have one wrinkle in the plan. With Sen. Dominici gone, so will all those earmarks and with NMDOT hundreds of millions of dollars in the hole, where will the money come from;' Texas? I think not!
With the national debt and trade deficit out of control, projects like this will be dependent on private sources which may be there..but at what cost?
El Paso and its leaders must not let this happen. We already are the major HUB for the border region. I am forwarding this to City Council and County Commissioners and the Chamber for their take.